Case studies · Transactions

Track Record

Hospital turnarounds, a national build-out, a public offering and a company started from scratch.

Each turnaround was run the same way: a plan built department by department, executed on site by experienced operators, and financed around what the operations could support. In every one, quality improved alongside the economics, because done right, efficiency and quality care drive each other.

Safety-net hospital system

Avanti Hospitals

$50M+

Improvement in annual system EBITDA over approximately three years

Role
Owner and operator
Period
2009–2019
Place
South and East Los Angeles

The condition

Four struggling hospitals in South and East Los Angeles, serving some of the most underserved and vulnerable communities in the country. Each was losing money, each depended heavily on government payers and supplemental payments, and for many of the people around it, each was the only hospital within reach. We acquired Memorial Hospital of Gardena and East Los Angeles Doctors Hospital in January 2009, Community Hospital of Huntington Park in April 2010, and Coast Plaza in 2011.

Joel Freedman · Co-founder

Joel Freedman and his team drove efficiency through every hospital, from the moment a patient arrived in the emergency department until the last claim was collected on appeal, and everything in between: patient flow, length of stay, documentation, staffing, purchasing and revenue cycle. Excess capacity was relicensed rather than carried, and the sub-acute units ran close to full, with waiting lists, absorbing overhead in beds that would otherwise have sat dark.

The numbers

  • Eliminated Ambulance diversion
  • 0.8 from 1.7 Agency nursing hours per patient day
  • −0.67 from +0.5 Average Medicare stay against national benchmark, days

What resulted

We succeeded at every level. Quality rose and so did the economics: annual system EBITDA across the four hospitals improved by more than $50 million over approximately three years.

Teaching hospital turnaround

Howard University Hospital

$77.4M

Swing in audited operating results within two years

Role
Manager, with a full executive team on site
Period
2014–2019
Place
Washington, D.C.

The condition

Howard University Hospital is the teaching hospital of Howard University and the safety-net institution for much of the District. In fiscal 2014 it lost $58.7 million from operations — enough to threaten the university itself.

The causes were ordinary ones. Medicare length of stay ran two days above benchmark, observation stood in for status decisions, documentation understated the acuity being treated, labor was staffed to a census that no longer existed, and purchasing had never been consolidated.

Joel Freedman · Management

Paladin Healthcare, led by Joel Freedman, took over management in October 2014, putting their own executives on site in the chief executive, chief financial and chief nursing seats. They worked every one of those problems at once: status and length of stay, documentation, staffing to census and a consolidated supply chain. Admissions rose 7.6 percent in the first year, against a market that grew half a percent.

The numbers

  • 0.62 from 2.10 Medicare length-of-stay gap, days
  • 1.48 from 1.26 Case mix index
  • High 30s from 34% CC and MCC capture
  • −45% Observation admissions
  • −8.7% Bed days
  • −23% Medical supplies
  • −44% General supplies

What resulted

The hospital reached positive EBIDA in July 2015, ten months into the engagement. Audited operating results improved from a $58.7 million loss in fiscal 2014 to $18.7 million of operating income in fiscal 2016, a $77.4 million swing within two years.

National hospital system

Prime Healthcare Services

16

Distressed hospitals acquired and turned around

Roles
Chief executive officer · Chief financial officer
Period
2001–2020
Place
Three states, growing to fourteen

Lex Reddy · Chief executive

As President and Chief Executive Officer from 2001 to 2012, Lex Reddy led the acquisition of sixteen distressed nonprofit and for-profit hospitals across three states, and ran the transition, integration and turnaround of each. He obtained California Attorney General approval for three nonprofit conversions, and raised approximately $1 billion of debt financing for the system from a major healthcare real estate investment trust, the Royal Bank of Canada and Healthcare Finance Group.

Thomson Reuters ranked Prime among the fifteen best health systems in the nation. Against a peer group of 320 systems it posted 24 percent lower mortality, 14.5 percent fewer medical complications and 32 percent fewer adverse patient safety incidents.

Michael Heather · Chief financial

From 2013 to 2020 Michael Heather helped lead Prime through its largest expansion, from 20 hospitals in four states to 45 in fourteen. As Chief Financial Officer he ran its acquisitions and capital raising, and oversaw revenue cycle, supply chain and the other functions that decide whether an acquired hospital turns around. Over the same period the team evaluated approximately 100 bankrupt or near-bankrupt hospitals.

The numbers

  • 45 from 20 Hospitals
  • 14 from 4 States
  • $5B from $2B Annual revenue
  • ~100 Distressed hospitals evaluated

Building a national delivery system

Prospect Medical Holdings

IPO

Led the 2005 public offering, then the 2010 take-private

Role
Chief financial officer
Period
2004–2013
Place
Southern California, then national

The starting point

When Michael Heather became Chief Financial Officer in 2004, Prospect Medical Holdings was a local operator of independent physician associations.

What he built

He built the financial platform for its growth. He led the 2005 initial public offering, financed the acquisition of hospitals and physician networks in the bank and high-yield bond markets, and in 2010 helped take the company private.

What resulted

By 2013 Prospect was a national integrated delivery system of clinics, hospitals and physician networks.

Company formation

CompWest Insurance Company

$50M + $50M

Equity raised and premium committed before the first policy

Role
Co-founder
Period
2004–2007
Place
California

The opportunity

In 2004 California’s workers’ compensation market faced a severe shortage of insurance capacity. The Legislature had just passed major reforms, and Joel Freedman saw a contrarian opportunity: a new carrier, built for mid-market employers, carrying none of the old claims that burdened incumbents.

What we built

Joel wrote the business plan, recruited the management team and raised $50 million of equity, led by Trident III, a fund managed by MMC Capital (now Stone Point Capital). Before the company wrote a single policy, he had secured $50 million of premium commitments from major brokers. CompWest was licensed by the California Department of Insurance in 2004, one of only two new workers’ compensation carriers capitalized in the state in several years.

What resulted

In 2007 CompWest was acquired by Accident Fund, a subsidiary of Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan. It continues to write workers’ compensation today as part of AF Group.

Quality

Quality and volume moved with the economics

  • 46th → 2nd Core quality measure ranking among 52 area hospitals Memorial Hospital of Gardena
  • 2.10 → 0.62 days Length of stay above the Medicare geometric mean, by MS-DRG, FY2014–FY2016 Howard University Hospital
  • 43 → 22 minutes Emergency department arrival to triage, FY2014–FY2016 Howard University Hospital
  • 4.35 → 2.44 hours Registry hours per acute patient day Memorial Hospital of Gardena
  • 28,173 → 36,030 Annual emergency visits, with emergency admissions rising from 2,533 to 4,608 Memorial Hospital of Gardena

Transaction capabilities

What we execute

Operating improvement does not solve every situation. Some require new capital, a change of ownership, or both. We advise on these processes from start to close, on both sides of the table, drawing on decades of having owned, operated and financed the institutions involved.

Sale and ownership change

  • Going-concern sale processes, run in parallel rather than as a single auction
  • Acquisition of distressed hospitals, systems and physician enterprises
  • Carve-outs and divestiture of non-core assets and real estate
  • Nonprofit conversions, including Attorney General approval
  • Affiliation and joint venture structures
  • Management agreements, with or without a path to ownership

Capital and financing

  • Senior credit facilities and revolving lines
  • Mortgage and asset-based facilities
  • Sale-leasebacks releasing value trapped in real estate
  • Equity private placements
  • Bank and high-yield bond financing
  • Public offerings and take-private transactions

Restructuring

  • Out-of-court recapitalizations and debt restructurings
  • Municipal bond and master trust workouts
  • Chapter 11 plan sponsorship and section 363 sales
  • Debtor-in-possession and exit financing
  • Creditor, bondholder and payer negotiation
  • Valuation and feasibility analysis that holds up under diligence

Transaction ledger

Selected transactions completed at prior organizations

More than 200 transactions totaling more than $5 billion, including more than $2 billion in healthcare, predominantly involving distressed businesses.

Company Type Value
American Academic Health System Acquisition $154M
Attends Healthcare Group Sale $129M
Corona Regional Medical Center Sale $120M
Prime Healthcare Group Credit facility $100M
Avanti Hospitals Sale-leaseback $85M
Desert Valley Hospital Mortgage facility $70M
Avanti Hospitals Credit facility $60M
CompWest Insurance Co. Equity private placement $50M
PaperPak Sale $42M
Memorial Hospital of Gardena & East Los Angeles Doctors Hospital Acquisition $35M
Sherman Oaks Hospital Sale-leaseback / credit facility $32M
Avanti Health System Mortgage $30M
Avanti Health System Credit facility $27M
Coast Plaza Hospital Acquisition $17.5M
Sherman Oaks Hospital Sale $17M
AccentCare Credit facility $15M
Community Hospital of Huntington Park Acquisition $4.5M
Centinela Freeman Acquisition Undisclosed